8 Man Football in PA?

Last night’s 81-0 Frazier win over Geibel had to be unsettling for both Frazier and Geibel’s players, coaches, and fans. No coach plans to throw up over 60 points. It takes a course of things to go mightily wrong for a score to get that lopsided. And even worse for Geibel is that they play a strong Tri-County South team in Beth Center next week.

There’s a shift going on in sports at the high school level and that shift is less kids playing them. In football alone, since 2010 there are 10,000 less kids nationwide football. And what you’re seeing locally is schools like Geibel having no more than 16-18 on it’s roster. I saw West Greene in a scrimmage and they had no more than 18 playing. They literally had more coaches on it’s sideline than they did players.  Just two years ago, Cornell folded its program due to a lack of players, and Imani Christian followed suit a few weeks ago.

From the outside looking in, it’s very easy to say that schools like Geibel, West Greene, or Avella should merge or co-op with another school.

What can the PIAA do to help these struggling programs?

I propose two ideas; either create a Class B for enrollments below 120 boys, or create 8-Man football.

8 man football is played in states like Texas, Kansas, Missouri, and other plain states, so why not here in Pennsylvania?

What 8-man football does at least is provide a division for schools that struggle to get enough kids out for football like Geibel, and allow schools like Imani and Cornell to restart their football programs. It also allows for even smaller schools like a Wilson Christian Academy, or Quigly Christian to start up a football program.

8-Man isn’t an ideal situation. But seeing teams get 80 points thrown on them isn’t ideal either. The team that wins, by such a large margin, isn’t getting anything out of winning that overwhelmingly. And I can’t think of how a team that loses by that large of a margin feels.

Lets get these schools in their own division somehow and allow them to rebuild their programs.


2 responses to “8 Man Football in PA?

  1. Says the man who hasnt had a team win a championship in 4 years? Whats wrong Ed…..all your roid boys graduate? Joey makes some good well researched points. Just bc its something TJ would OBVIOUSLY be against doesnt mean its a bad idea. Btw hows that million dollar wall holding up? TJ has alot of its own problems to worry about like how much taxes will rise to build ANOTHER new stadium and new high school like they want. Have you ever met Joey? No u probably dont. But please. Keep you eye on Clairton football. Maybe you will learn something and maybe the next time u have some talented players maybe ull play them instead of the school board members kids who throw like girls. Take YOUR babble and your crumbling feild back to snob hill. And stay there.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s